Detective Fiction by Edgar Allan Poe

March 24, 2021 by Essay Writer

Detective fiction is a type of inscription in which a detective is mechanized to resolve misconduct. The audience is dared to explain the wrongdoing by the hints delivered in advance. The detective reveals the response at the conclusion of the novel. When the story starts, crime is familiarized. In particular narratives, the erroneous individual is blamed for the crime to keep the reader locked in. Ultimately, the detective initiates an investigation to detect the guilt-ridden perpetrator. This paper describes the role of Edgar Allen Poe the father of detective fiction. The principal investigator story was created by Edgar Allan Poe and his small tale The Murders in Rue Morgue that he wrote in 1841 (Klein, 1999). In the story, two females are killed, and the police department has a tough time deciphering the circumstances.

Investigator Dupin leads his personal examination and resolves the offense when the law enforcement agency cannot. Poe is persistent in using Dupin in numerous additional short stories. The genre cultivated slightly generally through the 1800s. Victorian novelists, such as Wilkie Collins and Charles Dickens, engraved detective fiction. Nevertheless, when Sir Arthur Conan Doyle shaped Sherlock Holmes, the genre produced. Doyle wrote and completed fifty short stories as well as narratives around Sherlock Holmes with his sidekick Dr. Watson. Doyle’s characters are very common today. In the 1900s, numerous innovative detectives were introduced, safeguarding that the genre sustained growth. Some of the additional general investigators were Endeavor Morse and Gervase Fen, a formation of Edmund Crispin. Crispin is attributed to making the investigator genre more modern. William Legrand, the main character in “The Gold Bug,” shows specific characteristics with Poe’s famous unprofessional detective, Dupin. Legrand is of a memorable intimate, but because of financial adversities, he has been to close to poverty.

On the contrary, he comes from the French lineage from New Orleans. He resides lonely on an island near Charleston, South Carolina. Additionally, similar to Dupin, he surrogates between sorrow and enthusiasm, which directs the teller of tales to the uncertainty that he is the dupe of a class of insanity (Delamater, 1997). The basic evidence of the story is that Legrand is metaphorically nibbled by the gold bug once determining a portion of parchment on which he discovers a cipher with guidelines to the suppressed beauty of the adventurer Captain Kidd. As through the extraordinary significant Dupin stories, “The Gold Bug” emphases little on accomplishment than on the clarification of the phases to the resolution of its mystery. To crack the mystery of the cipher, Legrand establishes the critical potentials of the substandard detective: close consideration to the minute point, extensive information about language and mathematics, far reaching knowledge about his opponent which is Captain Kidd, and most important a perceptive intuition as well as a methodical reasoning ability.

Poe’s famous gothic stories of psychological obsession, such as “The Black Cat,” “The Tell-Tale Heart,” “The Fall of the House of Usher,” and “Ligeia,” seem at first glance entirely different from his logical stories of detection. In many ways, however, they are very similar: Both types depend on some secret guilt that must be exposed; in both, the central character is an unusual whose mind seems distant from the minds of ordinary men; and both types are elaborate puzzles filled with clues that must be tied together before the reader can understand their overall effect.”The Oblong Box” and “Thou Art the Man,” both written in 1844, are often cited as combining the gothic and the compelling core of Poe’s genius. The narrator of “The Oblong Box,” while on a packet-ship journey from Charleston, South Carolina, to New York City, becomes unusually curious about an oblong pine box that is kept in the stateroom of an old school acquaintance, Cornelius Wyatt (Poe & Richardson, 2009). In the course of the story, the narrator uses deductive processes to conclude that Wyatt, an artist, is smuggling to New York a copy of Leonardo da Vinci’s

“The Last Supper” done by a famous Florentine painter.When a storm threatens to sink the ship, Wyatt ties himself to the mysterious box and, to the horror of the survivors, falls into the sea with it. Not until a month after the event does the narrator learn that the box contained Wyatt’s wife embalmed in salt. Although earlier in the story the narrator prided himself on his superior acumen in guessing that the box included painting, at the conclusion he admits that his mistakes were the result of both his carelessness and his impulsiveness. The persistent deductive efforts of the narrator to explain the mystery of the oblong box, combined with the sense of horror that arises from the image of the artist’s plunging to his death with the corpse of his beautiful young wife, qualifies this story, although a minor tale in the Poe canon, as a unique combination of the gothic and the ratiocinative.

“Thou Art the Man,” though frequently categorized as a mockery of small-town life and behaviors, is likewise a stimulating but slight influence to the type. The story is expressed in a sarcastic tenor by a storyteller who suggests to an explanation for the vanishing of Mr. Barnabus Shuttleworthy. He is one of the town’s wealthiest and most celebrated appreciated inhabitants (Amper & Bloom, 2007). When Shuttleworthy’s nephew is suspected of killing the uncle, Charley Goodfellow, a near acquaintance of Shuttleworth, brands each exertion to protect the young man. Each term he expresses to elevate and back the alleged nephew, though, aids only to excavate the town’s people’s doubt of him.

Through the story, Goodfellow is mentioned as “Old Charley.’’ He is praised as a gentleman who is substantial, exposed, forthright, and truthful. At the story’s inference, he obtains an enormous box allegedly covering wine assured him by the killed man previous to his demise. When the box is opened, the partly lousy body of Shuttleworth sit down in the table, points his limb at Goodfellow, and speaks, “Thou art the man!” Goodfellow, not astonishingly, acknowledges to the homicide. The rudimentary satires of Charley’s of not being such a “good fellow” afterward and of his labors to have the nephew sentenced even as he fake to have him absolved are dominant to the story’s conspiracy, the extreme sarcasm emphases on the incomes by which Goodfellow is made to admit. It is Goodfellow’s honesty and uprightness that reasons the storyteller to suspicion from the start and therefore discovery the body, twig a part of monster jawbone depressed its gullet to root it to be seated up inside the case, and use ventriloquism to brand it appear as if the dead body says the arguments of the name. The story presents such characteristic detective-story agreements as the formation of untrue signs by the illicit and the detection of the felonious as the smallest likely suspect.

“The Mystery of Marie Rogêt,” although it also focuses on Dupin’s solving of a crime primarily from newspaper reports, is based on the murder of a young girl, Mary Cecilia Rogers, near New York City. Because the crime had not been solved when Poe wrote the story, he made use of the facts of the case to tell a story of the murder of a young Parisian girl, Marie Rogêt, as a means of demonstrating his superior deductive ability. The story ostensibly begins two years after the events of “The Murders in the Rue Morgue,” when the faultless of police, having unsuccessful to solve the Marie Rogêt case himself, doubts about his status and requests Dupin for assistance.

Dupin’s technique is that of the definitive wing chair investigator; he folds all the reproductions of the reporters articles that have interprets of the misconduct and circles about systematically investigative every one. He states the circumstance extra complicated than that of the Rue Morgue since, paradoxically, it appears so modest. One of the elements of the story that makes it less accessible than the other two Dupin tales is the extensive analysis of the newspaper articles in which Dupin engages— a report that makes the story read more like an article critical of newspaper techniques than a narrative story. In fact, what makes Poe able to propose a solution to the crime is not so much his knowledge of evil as his knowledge of the conventions of newspaper writing. Similarly, it was his knowledge of the meetings of novel book that made it possible for him to deduce the correct conclusion of Charles Dickens’s novel Barnaby Rudge: A Tale of the Riots of ’80 (1841) the previous year when he had read only one or two of the first installments.

Another aspect of “The Mystery of Marie Rogêt” that reflects Dupin’s deductive genius and that has been used by subsequent detective writers is his conviction that the usual error of the police is to pay too much attention to the immediate events while ignoring the external evidence. Both experience and right philosophy, says Dupin, show that truth arises more often from the seemingly irrelevant than from the so-called strictly relevant. By this means, Dupin eliminates the various hypotheses for the crime proposed by the newspapers and suggests his hypothesis, which is confirmed by the confession of the murderer (Poe, Tales of mystery and imagination, 2003).

Although “The Mystery of Marie Rogêt” contains some of the primary conventions that find their way into later detective stories, it is the least popular of the Dupin narratives not only because it contains much reasoning and exposition and minimal narrative but also because it is so long and convoluted. Of the many experts of detective fiction who have commented on Poe’s contribution to the genre, only Dorothy L. Sayers has praised “The Mystery of Marie Rogêt,” calling it a story especially for connoisseurs, a serious intellectual exercise rather than a sensational thriller such as “The Murders in the Rue Morgue.” The above are some of the work done by Allen Poe. From these stories, one can deduce that Detective Fiction is essential in helping in the training of the criminal investigators. From the stories, one can be able to gauge a lie or something real. On the other hand, the Detective fiction induces critical thinking of an individual. Therefore, it is essential to assist one in making a rational decision.


1. Amper, S., & Bloom, H. (2007). Bloom’s how to write about Edgar Allan Poe. New York: New York: Chelsea House.

2. Delamater, J. (1997). Theory and practice of classic detective fiction: prepared under the auspices of Hofstra University.

3. Westport, Conn. : Greenwood Pr.Klein, K. G. (1999). Diversity and detective fiction. Bowling Green, Ohio Bowling Green State Univ. Popular.

4. Poe, E. A. (2003). Tales of mystery and imagination. London: Collector’s Library. Poe, E. A., & Richardson, C. F. (2009). The complete works of Edgar Allan Poe. New York: Cosimo Classics.

Read more